Facebook made great strides by adding degrees to the “Like” button. A happy face, a heart, a sad face were all welcome additions to the simple thumbs up icon.

The problem is this: there isn’t enough granularity, particularly when rating photographs. Trying to assign a numeric rating in the comments, while allowing greater discrimination, isn’t the answer either because there’s no standard for what each number means.

I was pondering this when I remembered how they rate pain in the hospital. They have a chart, numbered 0 to 10, with faces showing differing pain levels and a text description. The descriptions are something like “10 – Extreme pain – Just kill me now” to “0 – No pain – My God! those drugs are good.”

Using this same idea, I’ve developed the following rating scale for photographs, 10 (best) to 0 (worst).

10 – You would pay real money for a print. You may add a + if you’d be willing to spend over $100 for a print, provided it came with a really nice frame.

9 – If you could get away with it, you’d claim you’d taken the photograph.

8 – You wish you’d taken the photograph.

7 – You would hang a print on your wall.

6 – You’d hang a print on the wall of a friend you didn’t like much.

5 – You’d hang it in a gallery.

4 – You’d hang it in a room at a Motel 6. Add a + if you’d leave the light on.

3 – You’d use it in an author-published book of poetry.

2 – You’d hang it in Hillary Clinton’s or Donald Trump’s office. (Use whichever is the most detested. Substitute other politician if desired.)

1 – You’d tell everyone that the photograph was made by Donald Trump or Hillary Clinton. (Same options above.)

0 – You’d pay money to make sure the photographer never worked again. Add a – if your jurisdiction has capital punishment and that wouldn’t matter.

I hope this contribution to the literature, modestly called the Frerichs Photography Rating Scale, will prove useful.

This entry was posted in Opinion, Photography.

    Don't miss other deathless prose like this!

    Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Post a Comment

Your email is never published nor shared. Required fields are marked *